Utah Wildlife Network discussion forum
Utah Wildlife Network
T-Shirts

"I am not against golf, since I cannot but suspect it keeps armies of the unworthy from discovering trout." — Paul O'Neil

bow and arrow on public land / aluminum shafts

Discussions about archery, archery equipment and hunting

bow and arrow on public land / aluminum shafts

Postby pkred » Mar 08, '10, 12:17

Can I have my bow on public land out of season?

Why do you use/don't use aluminum shafts?
"Politics is the will of the people corrupted by the greed of the individual"
User avatar
pkred
 
Posts: 523
Joined: Jul 09, '09, 3:36

Register as a UWN forum member and see fewer advertisements. It's easy and free.


Re: bow and arrow on public land / aluminum shafts

Postby dkhntrdstn » Mar 08, '10, 12:28

yes you can have your bow on public land. I use carbon arrows.Because I don't like the aluminum arrows.
In the Memory of Douglas M Gleed
3-28-1944-8-24-2004

RIP MASK
Real duck hunters do it with a long shaft.

Wishing I was out in the marsh..
User avatar
dkhntrdstn
 
Posts: 4596
Joined: Sep 07, '07, 3:52
Location: Salt Lake City, Utah

Re: bow and arrow on public land / aluminum shafts

Postby pkred » Mar 08, '10, 12:35

Cool. Why dont you like aluminum is it the weight... I ask this question cause i was out shooting this weekend, and I broke two carbon arrows tring to get them out a a plastic barrel I was shooting.
"Politics is the will of the people corrupted by the greed of the individual"
User avatar
pkred
 
Posts: 523
Joined: Jul 09, '09, 3:36

Re: bow and arrow on public land / aluminum shafts

Postby dkhntrdstn » Mar 08, '10, 12:40

pkred wrote:Cool. Why dont you like aluminum is it the weight... I ask this question cause i was out shooting this weekend, and I broke two carbon arrows tring to get them out a a plastic barrel I was shooting.


Yea that one reason and the other is if I miss and I would rather have the arrow brake then just bend and then try to straiten it out again. Plus I just don't like the way aluminum arrows fly.But that just me and there some people on here that still shoot the aluminum arrows and love them.
In the Memory of Douglas M Gleed
3-28-1944-8-24-2004

RIP MASK
Real duck hunters do it with a long shaft.

Wishing I was out in the marsh..
User avatar
dkhntrdstn
 
Posts: 4596
Joined: Sep 07, '07, 3:52
Location: Salt Lake City, Utah

Re: bow and arrow on public land / aluminum shafts

Postby stablebuck » Mar 08, '10, 2:20

pkred wrote:Cool. Why dont you like aluminum is it the weight... I ask this question cause i was out shooting this weekend, and I broke two carbon arrows tring to get them out a a plastic barrel I was shooting.


what brand arrows were you shooting??? I've shot my goldtips accidentally through a sheet of plywood and they were unscathed except for the vanes.
Some people say a cucumber tastes better pickled...

If you see a turtle on a fencepost you better know it didn't get there by itself...

http://www.bowhuntersofutah.net
User avatar
stablebuck
 
Posts: 1100
Joined: Nov 22, '07, 1:40
Location: Bountiful

Re: bow and arrow on public land / aluminum shafts

Postby pkred » Mar 08, '10, 2:35

to be honest I dont know they were the 35 dollar(for six) carbons form humphries in AF. The arrow penatrated well but any side to side flex on the shaft made it splinter. I did get one other arrow out successfully after I learned how easy they were to break. I'm on the cusp of buying new arrows and I want to stick with one kind. I dont have a lot of money so I can't afford high end arrows... This is why i was looking @ aluminum.
"Politics is the will of the people corrupted by the greed of the individual"
User avatar
pkred
 
Posts: 523
Joined: Jul 09, '09, 3:36

Re: bow and arrow on public land / aluminum shafts

Postby dkhntrdstn » Mar 08, '10, 2:41

pkred wrote:to be honest I dont know they were the 35 dollar(for six) carbons form humphries in AF. The arrow penatrated well but any side to side flex on the shaft made it splinter. I did get one other arrow out successfully after I learned how easy they were to break. I'm on the cusp of buying new arrows and I want to stick with one kind. I dont have a lot of money so I can't afford high end arrows... This is why i was looking @ aluminum.


Go with gold tips. They are great arrows and are priced dang good.Shoot xt hunters or the pros.Gold tip just come out with a new arrow.give them a try.You can buy a half doz for around 50 to 60 bucks.
In the Memory of Douglas M Gleed
3-28-1944-8-24-2004

RIP MASK
Real duck hunters do it with a long shaft.

Wishing I was out in the marsh..
User avatar
dkhntrdstn
 
Posts: 4596
Joined: Sep 07, '07, 3:52
Location: Salt Lake City, Utah

Register as a UWN forum member and see fewer advertisements. It's easy and free.


Re: bow and arrow on public land / aluminum shafts

Postby jahan » Mar 08, '10, 3:06

pkred wrote:to be honest I dont know they were the 35 dollar(for six) carbons form humphries in AF. The arrow penatrated well but any side to side flex on the shaft made it splinter. I did get one other arrow out successfully after I learned how easy they were to break. I'm on the cusp of buying new arrows and I want to stick with one kind. I dont have a lot of money so I can't afford high end arrows... This is why i was looking @ aluminum.


That would make me very nervous. The older carbon fiber arrows had the potential of exploding per say. They recommend flex testing your arrows now and again looking for splinters and such. If one of those arrows were to explode it would be very painful, carbon fiber splinters all over the place.

I have shot gold tips for many years and have only had a couple break and those were all user error, i.e. rock. :oops: :mrgreen:
If it feels good, it must be good

You stay classy Salt Lake City...
User avatar
jahan
 
Posts: 3644
Joined: Sep 07, '07, 2:30
Location: Sandy, UT

Re: bow and arrow on public land / aluminum shafts

Postby pkred » Mar 08, '10, 4:13

Thanks guys I'll look into the gold tips. I have plenty of user error arrows i have laid to rest too. :wink:
"Politics is the will of the people corrupted by the greed of the individual"
User avatar
pkred
 
Posts: 523
Joined: Jul 09, '09, 3:36

Re: bow and arrow on public land / aluminum shafts

Postby alpinebowman » Mar 08, '10, 5:40

I would also highly suggest you stop shooting plastic barrels because it won't matter what arrow you are shooting they are going to be damaged. Get yourself a decent target and your arrows will last a long time. I would suggest a yellow jacket broadhead and field point target. I have found they are the best target for the money.
alpinebowman

>>>---shots that are true pass right through--->
User avatar
alpinebowman
 
Posts: 411
Joined: Sep 24, '07, 4:47
Location: West Jordan UT

Next

Return to Archery

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: JuddCT and 8 guests

cron


Copyright © 2010 Utah Wildlife Network
 

cron